Martha Stewart Invades Facebook
Martha Stewart has had a presence on MySpace for some time, but has just recently opened an account on Facebook.
But let's take a look at Facebook. On Facebook, profiles are plain, and all generally look the same. Focus is more on the individual, their statistics, interests and their own content (which has made Facebook a top photo sharing site). And the custom there is generally to befriend only people that you have actual relationships with. The function to show how you know each person is built into the code which proves this.
Because of the differences in each site, maybe it wasn't best for Martha to just open up a profile as she has on MySpace. However, one can see why it was chosen to be done. With the success of the MySpace profile, someone decided that the next logical step was to duplicate it on Facebook. Surely, it will be successful to an extent, as there will be hardcore fans who are willing to let that transcend the normal unspoken rules of Facebook, but it probably wasn't the most appropriate implementation.
Facebook has recently added applications to allow users to spam-up their profiles in a controlled manner (unlike the ability to change backgrounds and font colors to make text unreadable a la MySpace). Wouldn't it have been more appropriate and effect to launch a Facebook application instead of a profile?
The application route has a number of benefits. First, purists (those who will only befriend those they actually know) would be more likely to accept her in the form of an application. They also would be able to enjoy whatever service that the application gave. The application would also be more visible, as it would be seen every time that the person's profile is viewed, and the host would view it quite often as well. The only loss of not having the profile would be the visibility in the user's RSS feed, but an application can actually take this to the next level. Instead of the user seeing Martha's updates, the application can prompt users to post their own updates in their RSS feed (or even do it automatically on approval) and all of their friends can see them as well.
It should be obvious by this point that creating an application versus a profile would be a more efficient way to go viral. Aside from what has already been discussed, users also have the ability to automatically prompt other users after they have added the application - and many do. These automatic invitations come from the user specifically and not from Martha, therefore their effectiveness is sure to be heightened. Also, recipients of invitations must make an effort to accept or deny them, so cannot be as ignored.
So marketers and PR agents, please learn to see the differences between MySpace and Facebook and learn to respect those differences - it will benefit you and your client in the end.
Labels: facebook, martha stewart, myspace, social networks

